11′s: Since it worked so well last time, I read the same poem to you and the 9′s. Only with you, I went into greater depth and gave you an entirely different and significantly harder response to write. The poem was Margaret Atwood’s Boredom, a poem in which she goes into excruciating detail about the minutiae of her childhood. In fact, she uses the word minutiae — and since teaching you this poem I have found at least five specific times when I’ve been able to use the word. It’s my new favourite word, edging out pusillanimous, my old favourite word.
Your written response was to look at one of three things: the theme of death or childhood or growing awareness/maturity in the poem. You were also to remember the cardinal rules of poetry analysis: Your feelings don’t count. Whether you like the poem or the poet doesn’t count. What counts is exactly what is in the poem and how the poet uses language and poetic devices to get meaning across. It’s a harsh world, this poetic analysis. But there you go. No more Shel Silverstein. This is SciencePoetry.
Above, you can see two pictures of Margaret Atwood that are straight out of the poem. She’s about four years old in the first one and seventeen in the second. Doesn’t she look like she’s plotting her escape in the teenage one?
9′s: We looked at exactly the same poem as the 11′s did: Boredom. First of all, you made a list of the things that make a person bored and then considered the elements of boredom. When do we get bored? Why do we get bored?
Then, we looked at the denotation of words (dictionary meaning), and how Atwood uses repetition to show her boredom. We dissected all of the pieces of the poem and then we figured out the meaning. That is exactly what you will be doing when you do the Poem Analysis.